Emanuel Law Group

Free Consultation
(800) 308-0870

San Mateo (650) 369-8900
San Francisco (415) 399-1112
San Jose (408) 943-8833

Llame hoy para una Consulta Inicial Gratuita
(800) 308-0870

Oficina de San Mateo (650) 369-8900
Oficina de San Francisco (415) 399-1112
Oficina de San Jose (408) 943-8833
  • Home
  • Attorney Bios
    • Todd P. Emanuel
    • Pamela E. Glazner
  • Practice Areas
    • Sexual Assault
    • Wrongful Death
    • Traumatic Brain Injuries
    • Catastrophic Injuries
  • Results
    • Major Win
  • Testimonials
  • Blog
  • Contact
  • Español
  • Áreas de Práctica
    • Abogados De Heridas Personales Del Área De La Bahía
  • Descripción De La Firma
    • Todd P. Emanuel
    • Gary Simms, Of Counsel
  • English
You are here: Home / Injury Settlements / When is it a good time to settle a personal injury lawsuit?

When is it a good time to settle a personal injury lawsuit?

Todd P. Emanuel March 14, 2018 Leave a Comment

There are normally many opportunities to try to settle your case before trial.  In most personal injury cases, the statute of limitations is two years from the day of the incident.

In some cases, we may try to settle without filing a lawsuit. This is possible when we have enough evidence to evaluate past and future damages, and when the party at fault is cooperative in providing an early disclosure of insurance policy limits.

If we are unhappy with the outcome of pre-litigation settlement negotiations, we will likely go ahead and file a lawsuit. Sometimes the filing of the lawsuit by itself persuades the defense to make a more reasonable settlement offer.  In many cases, we find it advantageous to go ahead and file a lawsuit immediately.

As a general rule, when we demand a large sum of money to settle a case, the defense will insist on obtaining a lot of information from our client. This is accomplished through informal cooperation, depositions, written discovery and sometimes medical examinations.  In clear liability cases that proceed to litigation, it is common to discuss a settlement after this information is exchanged. Where there are significant long-term injuries, it is incumbent on us to use credible evidence to demonstrate the value of those injuries before we make a serious settlement demand.

In cases in which the defense can contest liability, we might take depositions from those who claim to support the defense position before choosing to talk about a settlement.

Q: Is it better to settle cases early?

It depends. Every case is unique and every client is unique. Before determining a settlement position, we need sufficient time to do a comprehensive evaluation of the key issues in the case.

We must be able to answer the following questions:

  • Can we prove who was at fault?
  • What is the nature and extent of our client’s injuries and damages?
  • What is the financial condition of the person or corporation at fault?
  • Is there sufficient insurance and/or assets to fully compensate our client?
  • Are there multiple parties at fault?
  • If the defense makes a settlement offer, what are the costs and risks going forward if we reject that settlement offer?

Those questions are always important in determining when to consider settling and for how much money. Just as important as an understanding of the case is, we need to understand our client’s particular circumstances. For example, clients who have terminal illness unrelated to the case will typically want to settle early so they can focus the remainder of their life on other seemingly more important matters.

Another example is if you have a client without health insurance. We need to make sure the settlement is sufficient to cover future medical care related to our client’s injuries.

There is no bright line rule as to whether it is better to settle early versus going through the process of litigation versus going all the way to a juror verdict.

Q: Does the defense usually offer more money immediately before trial?

Don’t count on it.

If you want to settle your case but you strategize to hold out until the last minute, there’s no guarantee that the defense will increase the settlement offer.   Also, by holding out you risk a smaller net outcome because undoubtedly your attorney is investing more money on expert witnesses, fancy exhibits, subpoenas, jury fees, etc. as the case proceeds and gets closer to trial.

Sometimes, you can achieve a better settlement offer on the day of trial simply because the defense changes its position.

However, the best way of obtaining a better settlement offer later in the process is to show the opposition something “new and improved” about your case such as a compelling witness or powerful animation of the incident, or by tearing apart their star defense expert at a pre-trial deposition.   If you want a better settlement offer later in the game, you need to make it happen by the persuasive use of evidence.

 

Filed Under: Injury Settlements, Personal Injury Lawsuits, Personal Injury Lawyers

Join the Conversation

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Contact Us Today

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Contacta con nosotros hoy

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

SIGN UP FOR OUR NEWSLETTER

Recent Blog Posts

  • Why Do You Need a Bicycle Accident Attorney in the Bay Area?
  • When to Call a Truck Accident Attorney in Silicon Valley
  • Things to Consider When Hiring a Motorcycle Accident Attorney
  • Dog Owners Can be Liable for Injuries Caused by Their Animals
  • Domestic Violence Attorney: Take Back Control of Your Life

Office Locations

Ubicaciones de Oficinas

San Mateo Office

411 Borel Avenue, Suite 425
San Mateo, CA 94402
(800) 308-0870 Main
(650) 369-8900 Ext. 1015

Oficina de San Mateo

411 Borel Avenue, Suite 425
San Mateo, CA 94402
(800) 308-0870 Principal
(650) 369-8900 Ext. 1015

San Francisco Office

505 Montgomery St, 11th Floor
San Francisco, CA 94111
(415) 399-1112

Oficina de San Francisco

505 Montgomery St, 11th Floor
San Francisco, CA 94111
(415) 399-1112

San Jose Office

2880 Zanker Rd, #203
San Jose, CA 95134
(408) 943-8833

Oficina de San Jose

2880 Zanker Rd, #203
San Jose, CA 95134
(408) 943-8833

©2025 Emanuel Law Group. All Rights Reserved. Disclaimer | Privacy Policy
Sign Up for Our Newsletter!